Skip to main content

Remove automatic absolute positioning in autolayout


Johann3

I’ve noticed Figma adding absolute positioning to certain elements in an autolayout frame automatically. This is unexpected, unpredictable and simply annoying behavior. Adding several more steps to creating a simple autolayout.

Most autolayout frames don’t have an absolute positioned element. So it would be best to leave this button as a manual toggle.

I’d be happy if we could turn this behavior off via a user-setting.

Vote for the feature request if you agree!

13 replies

  • 1 reply
  • February 16, 2024

I’ve noticed this too, it’s very frustrating.


Gayani_S
Figmate
  • Community Support
  • 2069 replies
  • February 20, 2024

Hey there, thank you for your feedback! I’ve changed the category from “General Discussion” to “Share an Idea”. I am going to share this feedback internally with the teams for consideration.
Also, feel free to upvote this post. This helps us roadmap future updates.

Thank you!


Pantea_Parsa

I have the same issue, very confusing


Nicholas_Tomlinson

I was such a huge fan of absolute positioning in Figma when it was first introduced, and still am. But the fact that it automatically happens in some cases for auto layout is certainly frustrating because I don’t always notice it and end up confused on why my components are acting weird. It would be great to have the option to turn off the auto-absolute positioning feature. I hope to see this change in the very near future.


matthewcorreia

Absolute positioning should never happen automatically. It’s always an exception, particularly when developers are expected to look at the design in terms of intention and structure. And it can cause so many unexpected issues in design and code when it comes to responsive behaviour, reflow and the cascade. Now with every new AL frame I need to toggle absolute positioning on all children on and off, to ensure I don’t miss any. I love most of what Figma does; some decisions are slightly annoying, but this one drives me up the wall daily. Although I do see real value in having it, I would prefer no absolute positioning at all, than have it being applied automatically; particularly in the context of a layout feature that is specifically supposed to follow a set of (flex) rules.


Michael56

This behavior is so frustrating. It should be a bug fix rather than a feature request. Automatically turning on absolute positioning for SOME objects in an autolayout frame is just bizarre and frustrating.


Nellya
  • Power Member
  • 567 replies
  • July 25, 2024

This feature should stay in Suggest auto layout, but removed from the regular one


Kathryn_W
  • 2 replies
  • July 25, 2024

This happens to me all the time, I even looked it up and figured out what the heck it was a few months ago so I finally understand why it happens. but then I forgot the name and I have been googling for several days now to find it again and I STILL haven’t found the way to REMOVE it without having to watch a video. Why on earth is there not a context menu option to remove absolute positioning when it is not something that I asked for? It should be easy to get rid of. Instead I’m randomly copying other elements to try to get one that doesn’t have it. I know there’s a way to do it but seriously I should not have to go on a help document deep dive to find this.


Hello please fix absolute position. I’m getting frustrated when I hide something in a component, and after unhiding that element, it goes to the absolute position for that fix issue, which I’ve copied again and again. I find it very frustrating. Fix that ASAP.


Yuxin
  • 3 replies
  • August 12, 2024

This is so frustrating. Please fix it


kleja
  • New Member
  • 7 replies
  • September 19, 2024

I was about to create a new post because of this frustrating “feature” I haven’t seen it save time even once. This behavior is completely unpredictable and disrupts layouts that we expected to work seamlessly.

Before this new behavior, I relied on auto layout to organize my designs. I could confidently through a bunch of items, knowing that with just a press of Shift + A, everything would be as expected. However, now Figma attempts to predict how the layout should be, automatically positioning layers to absolute. It takes considerable time to fix each layer that ends up in a different component corner.

Please remove this feature or give us an option to opt out.


Ryan71
  • 1 reply
  • September 19, 2024

This is pretty aggravating, I know this is semantics, but it is particularly aggravating this is being addressed as a feature and not a bug. This isn’t the expected action and slows down the workflow considerably.

Please fix this ASAP.


djv
Figmate
  • Community Support
  • 4779 replies
  • September 19, 2024

Hey All, thanks for your votes and continued feedback!

Can you please provide examples of what you’re finding aggravating and are being unexpectedly absolute positioned via a screen recording?

With your examples, we can build a case to advocate for revisiting our current absolute positioning heuristics, especially how we decide to absolute position nodes when using the Shift+A shortcut.


Reply


Cookie policy

We use cookies to enhance and personalize your experience. If you accept you agree to our full cookie policy. Learn more about our cookies.

 
Cookie settings