Skip to main content

The new 'Aspect Ratio' change is bad. (UI3)

  • February 11, 2025
  • 3 replies
  • 116 views

Richard_Silcock

Hello,

 

I’m generally pretty chill about product updates, and I understand that companies need to evolve and improve their features Figma included. But honestly, I think you're heading in the wrong direction when it comes to prioritisation.

Obviously, us the users don’t get insight into your development plans until changes are released. But I urge you to reconsider your product roadmap in terms of real, tangible benefits for designers.We’re the ones paying you after all…

The new UI3 update introduces several changes that just don’t align with fundamental design principles. Since the rise of tools like Photoshop in the 1990s, there has been an industry standard in layout alignments, UI iconography, and UX best practices. Disrupting these conventions for the sake of change feels counterproductive.

I understand the ambition to create the best possible software, but some of these decisions feel like change for change’s sake. With UI3, it genuinely feels like I’m driving in reverse, dealing with UX decisions that hinder usability rather than improve it.

Ok, now, the main reason I’m writing this…

Once again, Figma is reinventing the wheel when there’s no need to. It feels as though product changes are being picked from a hat just to meet a release quota. Case in point: the recent update to the padlock/chain ‘locked ratio’ icon.

I received a signposting message saying something about the padlock/chain icon had been replaced with a square block containing aspect ratio details. Honestly I just dismissed it…

(For context: I refuse to use the new UI3 layout, so this is within the classic setup.)

 

Why was this changed?

It makes absolutely no sense. The padlock/chain icon is a universal standard in design software—it’s instantly recognisable and has been for years. In contrast, the new icon is typically associated with video media. Did no one stop to consider the impact of this change?

Now, instead of instinctively clicking the padlock/chain, I have to pause and search for this new, unfamiliar icon. It disrupts my workflow and slows me down. From a UX perspective, has anyone assessed this change in terms of cognitive load?

To make things worse, this new icon now sits alongside the border radius control, making quick identification even more confusing. A glance at the interface should make things clearer, not more convoluted.

Example

Frankly, it’s baffling.

I know this feedback will likely fall on deaf ears within the all-seeing, all-knowing product team (if it even gets that far). But sometimes, the right call is to reverse a decision, no matter how difficult or disheartening it may be. With the rise of alternatives like Penpot, switching to a different design platform is becoming a far easier decision for teams than it used to be.

Please change the icon back or allow me to change it.

3 replies

Marek.dg
  • New Participant
  • 6 replies
  • February 11, 2025

I agree with the feedback Richard wrote. And want to add another issue I found with this change. 😥

I’ve the nudge amount set on 8px for big nudges. This is now broken when an instance is placed in a frame with auto layout turned on.

When I change the height from 72px using Shift + Arrow down to apply the nudge amount it will go to 63,84px. 
(When I go up it will go from 72px → 80,16px)

It feels like the feature wasn't tested that well before release.☹️

H 72px → 63,84px   |   Should be 64px

 


Alessandro_Suraci1

This very small change has irked me to a level I didn’t think possible.

  • The new icon makes no sense
  • When I manually enter a value, you need to respect that value, not round it

This is nonsense:

  1. select an image layer
  2. Lock aspect ratio
  3. change the height to a manually inputted value (e.g. 72px)

Result: the height changes to 71,65px and the width to a round number; if I made the change to several images at once, now the height value shows as “mixed” (because each image has a slightly different height), making it impossible to see what value they’re set on.


dealchecker
  • New Member
  • 1 reply
  • February 27, 2025

The new lock icon is bad. I need to wait for the popup to know what’s up there.


Reply


Cookie policy

We use cookies to enhance and personalize your experience. If you accept you agree to our full cookie policy. Learn more about our cookies.

 
Cookie settings