I would love to get help with this problem I’ve been stuck on for a while. Once I click on one of my buttons, I want it to be an animation that shows I’m clicking on the button if that makes sense! Once I click on the button, I don’t want it just going instantly to the next screen but that it will first show quickly the button being clicked on in a motion. Is this possible with Figma? I hope my question makes sense! 
Yes, you can use after delay prototype triggers to do that. Open overlay of a button in initial state on click, then from this overlay swap to the animated button overlay with Smart Animate on after delay 1ms trigger, then from the second overlay navigate to the necessary screen on after delay trigger 1ms.