Ah I see now this is probably disabled. Wasn’t clear to me at first because I came to the highlighter before the pencil. Might make more sense for this to just be hidden if it’s not available.

Consider it a feature request to allow custom highlighter colors.

Hey Dave, thanks for your feedback! I totally get how that could be confusing, especially if you started with the highlighter tool.

I’ve noted this as a feature request for custom highlighter colors, and I’ve updated your topic title and moved it to the ‘Suggest a feature’ category so it’s clearer for others in the community. Thank you