Hi. I created a frame as master component. I created an instance of that component.
Now I like to paste an object into that instance. It is not possible. My goal: Insert new objects into an instance component without changing the master component. How can I solve this?
Thanks.
Best answer by Arip Rusli
Yes, Figma components doesn’t work like CSS. It doesn’t have a cascade system, so hiding elements in one instance won’t affect others except you hiding it from the master components.
For more control, you can use component properties or variants, though they need setup. (Take a lot of times sometimes but very useful for bigger projects)
Or for a quick fix: hide 5 vectors in the master component, then unhide them in the instances where you want them visible.
You can't add a new element/component to the instance unless you detach it, but that’s not a recommended. You need to add the element in the main component, then just hide it if you don’t want it to show in other designs.
Yes, Figma components doesn’t work like CSS. It doesn’t have a cascade system, so hiding elements in one instance won’t affect others except you hiding it from the master components.
For more control, you can use component properties or variants, though they need setup. (Take a lot of times sometimes but very useful for bigger projects)
Or for a quick fix: hide 5 vectors in the master component, then unhide them in the instances where you want them visible.
Hey Arip, that’s a helpful idea with hiding all vectors in the master and than unhide a single vector in the instances. I will give the feature component a try. But it seems, that it will not fit to my needs.
@AndreasB You may want to check out the Instance Utils plugin for Figma. It’ll allow you more control over component instances without detaching.
You have a few options though. One option is to use the concept of “component slots”. There are plugins to help like Slot Editor or Instance Utils as mentioned above, or you can create 1 or more “slots” manually. Then, you can create a local component and use instance swapping to swap out the slot for the local component. Then you’re free to edit the local component parent as needed.
Otherwise, as @Arip Rusli mentioned, you can determine your maximum number of needed items in a component and hide them by default, then turning on the amount needed in any instance. You can also optionally create variants with different numbers of layers/vectors/etc shown or included.
I still don't understand the possibilities and concepts of the two plugins. I'll have to take another look at it.
The essential thing for me is that you can somehow realize a concept of parents and children, where the relationship remains and you can still set the properties for a child, which then win over the same property of the parent. Exactly the way it works in CSS.
The normal function of components “Each instance always has completely identical properties to all others” and “You can only make layers of an instance invisible” is not helpful for me. I find that far too confusing and redundant.
Think of Figma components more like templates. Or in some ways similar to react components as opposed to CSS styles. There’s a master component, then instances are copies of it.
One of the main reasons for Figma components is to increase consistency in a design or design system. This is why they feel limited in some ways. It’s by design.
Instances strictly inherit all properties from the master. You can’t add or remove layers, but you can hide or show them or override various properties like text content/fill/layer styles/etc. In that way, with overriding properties, it is similar to CSS. Children inherit the parent’s properties by default, but you can override those.
Component properties and variants will be really helpful for getting what you need out of components as well.
As far as the plugins I mentioned, I recommend checking out this video from the Instance Utils creator. The main thing to know is that it allows you to reorder, add, or remove layers to component instance without needing to detach from the parent component. There are some other helpful videos on their YouTube channel as well.
Some Figma features that are maybe more similar to CSS you should look into:
Variables: store values like colors, spacing, typography to be applied to objects in a design that can then be edited all in one place. There’s also variable modes that can be used for say, light/dark mode, or mobile/desktop sizing. You can also set variables that reference other variables, so they can kind of cascade in a way.
Styles: Kind of like CSS classes. They bundle properties like fill, stroke, typography, and effects into reusable styles that can be applied to any layer. The bundled properties can also reference variables if you wish.
If you’re thinking strongly in terms of CSS, maybe start with variables for foundational values like CSS variables, then apply those with styles to be reused easily like CSS classes. These styles and variables can be applied to components or items inside components as well.
